Critiquing the OECD’s Employment Protection Legislation Index for individual dismissals: The importance of procedural requirements
Key EU agencies have successfully urged member states to scale back employment protection legislation as a solution to unemployment. The economic arguments for this reform are mixed, with recent empirical evidence largely unsupportive. Critics have also raised doubts about the accuracy of the OECD’s Employment Protection Legislation Index, which is the principal method EU agencies use to target so-called high-protection regimes. This article supplements existing criticisms of the OECD index by arguing that it fails to account for procedural requirements in assessing the difficulties and costs of carrying out individual dismissals. Evidence from New Zealand, ostensibly a low-protection country, demonstrates procedural requirements can pose the main impediments to carrying out individual dismissals. This suggests the need for revision of the OECD Employment Protection Legislation Index or the use of other indices instead.
|Author(s)||M. Harcourt, G. Gall, A.S. Raman, H. Lam, R. Croucher|
|Year of publication||Jun, 2019|
|Journal||Economic and Industrial Democracy|
|Website / Document||Visit|
- New trade union strategies for new forms of employment, 2019. E. Dockès.
- Economics of Artificial Intelligence: Implications for the Future of Work, 2019. E. Ernst, R. Merola, Daniel Samaan.
- Work, social protection and the middle classes: What future in the digital age? 2019. B. Palier.
- The state of the German social insurance state: Reform and resilience, 2019. F. Blank.
- Part-time and Partly Equal: Gender and Work in the Netherlands, 2019. OECD.
- Handreiking arbomaatregelen Uitzendwerk, 2019. SER.
- Naar een normalisering van platformwerk? 2019. R.F. Hoekstra.
- De sociale staat van Nederland 2019, 2019. A. Wennekers, J. Boelhouwer, C. van Campen, J. Kullberg.
- Werkgeversgedrag. Werving en behoud van personeel, 2019. UWV.
- Arbeidsparticipatie, gewerkte uren en economische zelfstandigheid van vrouwen, 2019. Y. Adema, K. Folmer, S. Rabaté, D. Visser, M. Vlekke.